Hi Anthony!
Thanks so much for sharing your wonderful spaghetti sauce recipe along with such detailed and informative instructions! If you get a chance, I’d love to know the answers to the following questions:
1.) In the recipe for the sauce, you state that it calls for either (2) 28 oz. cans of Tomato Puree' ("Hunts") OR (2) 28 oz. cans of Tomato Sauce ("Progresso"). However, at the store, I mistakenly picked up (2) 28 oz. cans of Progresso Tomato Puree’ (instead of the Hunts brand, as specifically indicated for the 28 oz. cans of puree’, and not the progresso ‘sauce’). QUESTION: Why do you call for 28 oz. cans of Hunt’s Puree, or Progresso Sauce? As I understand it, puree’ is somewhat thicker than sauce. Is there a significant difference between Hunt’s tomato puree and Progresso tomato sauce that I should be aware of? Is it okay to use the Progresso brand 28 oz. cans of puree’ instead of Progresso brand sauce here? Why the distinction between brands, or whether the item is labeled as ‘sauce’ or ‘puree’, if the amount used is the same – (2) 28 oz. cans?
2.) What is the purpose of mincing the garlic cloves involved – as opposed to pressing them through a garlic press – for the sauce recipe? What is the difference, or reason, to manually mince the garlic instead of simply crushing it (aside from having garlic-smelling fingers, of course)? Is it okay to just crush the garlic through a store-bought garlic press here? Thanks in advance and once more for your fabulous recipe and cooking tips! Yours,)

John
Hi John,
These are great questions. I see you are a man of details, I like that, always makes a better end product for sure :-)
1.) To answer your first question about the Puree vs. the sauce; I'm glad you brought this to my attention. I've been meaning to update the sauce about this very subject. I have found that using the Sauce in lieu of the puree' produces better results. I had them both on there because I was undecided. There seems to be little differences between the two in regards to final taste, however after I have experimented with this several times, well ok, maybe 20 or 30 times ;-) I am certain that the "tomato sauce" is the better way to go. In regards to the brand names, I do find Hunt's to make a superior product than the other brands out there, but overall the difference seems minor. I am going to update my site to reflect the use of tomato sauce only and Hunt's only to put aside any future confusion, so again, I thank you for reminding me of this. it was on my never ending loooong list of things to do.
2.) In regards to the garlic, well, the short answer is mincing the garlic is how grandma Salerno and my Mom did so it is how I do it. Kinda like family gospel, know what I mean? Grandma would NOT approve of a new fangled garlic press thingy ;-) However, I do prefer having the little small chunks of garlic in the sauce and in the meatballs vs.. the crushed garlic. Wirth the crushed garlic there are no little chunks of garlic to speak of really, your left with an apple sauce consistency that pretty much gets lost in the sauce. You loose the visual of actually seeing the garlic chunks in the sauce and on the edge of the meatballs. Presentation is a hugs part of the overall experience of enjoying the food. Plus I feel you get a more robust flavor with the fresh minced vs. the crushed. There you have my philosophy on the garlic, plus it would just not be the same if my fingers did not smell like garlic the whole day, something would seem to be a miss if that where not so.Hope this helps :-) If you tackle the sauce be sure to let me know how it all comes out and feel free to send me fun photos of the event :-) Would love to have more photos for my Visitors Photo's section. happy cooking and happy times!!!!?.
Ciao,
~8-) Anthony
Anthony!
Thanks so much for your quick response and the clarification – it makes sense. (I agree, I’m a Hunt’s fan myself, I just realized I grabbed the wrong thing b/c I was in a hurry at the time.) I understand what you’re saying about the garlic! In fact, I’ve found that most professional chefs appear to recommend mincing garlic instead of using a press, for exactly some of the same reasons you do. I think the larger chunks are more pungent and would give off more flavor into the sauce. I love the smell of garlic so much that I won’t mind it on my fingers, so I’m going to mince away. Anyway, thanks again for responding and providing this great stuff on the internet! It’s rare to find quality information out there. I’ll let you know how it turns out – making it for my girlfriend’s 44th birthday.
John